From Publishers Weekly
Ph.D. and soon-to-be English professor Sarah Deane reluctantly returns to sleuthing in this assured contemporary cozy by veteran Borthwick (Coup de Grce, etc.). Sarah's in-laws, Elspeth and John McKenzie, have left the academic world of Cambridge, Mass., to live in the new, perfectly planned and designed Maine community of Ocean Tide. With bike trails, golf course, pool, beach and a breathtaking view of Penobscot Bay, the place should be perfect for the couple, but John is having trouble adjusting. John's son, Alex, and Sarah hope that he'll eventually fit in, but his misgivings prove to be well founded. The discovery of a dead body (delicately depicted on the dust jacket with no traces of violence) on the pristine golf course is just the first in a series of catastrophic events that soon affect the whole family. Sarah, known for her past crime-solving experience, promises herself that she won't get involved in the investigation. As the family becomes more entangled, she remains resolute until circumstances lead her into personal danger. While the reader may be as frustrated as Sarah by her vow to remain aloof, her doing so helps us better understand the lovable, realistic McKenzie family. Their down-to-earth personalities provide a vivid contrast to the Disneyland-like community and its driven director and staff. From the fog that sometimes engulfs the land to the crystal clear Maine days, this novel will delight existing Borthwick fans and should attract new ones. Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
On the golf course of a retirement community on the coast of Maine, a dead body is discovered. In the latest Sarah Deane mystery, the recently out-of-work English professor and amateur sleuth looks into the mysterious goings-on at the development called Ocean Tide. Another body promptly turns up, and Sarah discovers that there are secrets among some of the community's residents. Like the previous entries in the series, this is a gentle novel with a stately pace and comfortable characters. (Think Murder, She Wrote without Jessica Fletcher.) The story is told in the classic whodunit format, bringing together a large cast of characters, all of whom are suspects in a drawing-room mystery (this time without the drawing room). Readers are encouraged to settle in, get to know the players, soak up the cozy ambience, and see if they can figure out the solution. Those who favor past-paced plots, hard-edged dialogue, and plenty of action may find this novel a tad lethargic, but one reader's lethargy is another's cozy. David Pitt
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
Review
"We can recognize cozy country when we sink our sensible walking shoes in it...
Borthwick does this sort of thing beautifully in her durable series."--The New York Times Book Review
"Just when you figured she couldn't get much better, Borthwick kick[s] it up another notch."-Rockland (ME) Courier-Gazette
"From the fog that sometimes engulfs the land to the crystal clear Maine days, this novel will delight existing Borthwick fans and should attract new ones."-Publishers Weekly
"[Borthwick] has a sharp eye for character and setting."-Chicago Tribune
Book Description
During an especially cold, rainy May, three families move to the recently opened Ocean Tide community on the coast of Maine. Not long after their arrival, a decaying corpse is found lying in the rough of their beautifully manicured golf course-disrupting the idyllic community.
When a second body is discovered in a fertilizer shed, just yards away from the seventeenth green, the local authorities are puzzled over the sudden rash of dead bodies and their link to Ocean Tide's newest arrivals.
Despite her own misgivings and her husband Alex's warnings, Sarah Deane, an English professor and sometime amateur sleuth, becomes entangled in the investigation. What she uncovers promises to rock the very foundation of the Ocean Tide community.
J. S. Borthwick keeps us guessing with another sharp and literate Sarah Deane mystery.
Murder in the Rough FROM THE PUBLISHER
"During an especially cold, rainy May, three families move to the recently opened Ocean Tide community on the coast of Maine. Not long after their arrival, a decaying corpse is found lying in the rough of their beautifully manicured golf course, disrupting the idyllic community." "When a second body is discovered in a fertilizer shed just yards away from the seventeenth green, the local authorities are puzzled over the sudden rash of dead bodies and their link to Ocean Tide's newest arrivals." Despite her own misgivings and her husband Alex's warnings, Sarah Deane, an English professor and sometime amateur sleuth, becomes entangled in the investigation. What she uncovers promises to rock the very foundation of the Ocean Tide community.
FROM THE CRITICS
Publishers Weekly
Ph.D. and soon-to-be English professor Sarah Deane reluctantly returns to sleuthing in this assured contemporary cozy by veteran Borthwick (Coup de Gr ce, etc.). Sarah's in-laws, Elspeth and John McKenzie, have left the academic world of Cambridge, Mass., to live in the new, perfectly planned and designed Maine community of Ocean Tide. With bike trails, golf course, pool, beach and a breathtaking view of Penobscot Bay, the place should be perfect for the couple, but John is having trouble adjusting. John's son, Alex, and Sarah hope that he'll eventually fit in, but his misgivings prove to be well founded. The discovery of a dead body (delicately depicted on the dust jacket with no traces of violence) on the pristine golf course is just the first in a series of catastrophic events that soon affect the whole family. Sarah, known for her past crime-solving experience, promises herself that she won't get involved in the investigation. As the family becomes more entangled, she remains resolute until circumstances lead her into personal danger. While the reader may be as frustrated as Sarah by her vow to remain aloof, her doing so helps us better understand the lovable, realistic McKenzie family. Their down-to-earth personalities provide a vivid contrast to the Disneyland-like community and its driven director and staff. From the fog that sometimes engulfs the land to the crystal clear Maine days, this novel will delight existing Borthwick fans and should attract new ones. (Mar. 25) Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information.
Kirkus Reviews
English teacher/inadvertent homicide sleuth Sarah Deane (Coup de Grace, 2000, etc.) once again finds herself surrounded by bodies, this time while visiting her husband Alex's parents, John and Elspeth, in their new digs at Maine's Ocean Tide leisure community. Jason Colley, the first victim, is strangled with a bicycle chain just off the putting green. Then Ned, his dad, is found buried under massive fertilizer bags in a groundskeeper's shed. Resort manager Joseph Martinelli is beside himself, particularly when the cops close the golf course, residents' bicycles keep disappearing, and a trusted staff member suddenly decamps for Paris. Meanwhile, as she's walking Patsy, the family Irish wolfhound, Sarah stumbles on another body, her father-in-law's irascible nonagenarian uncle Fergus, niblicked to death in a sand trap. Then young Dylan Colley disappears in the fog. Sarah finds him, loses him again, and ultimately winds up trussed beside him in a greenhouse basement. They escape, the bad 'uns are caught, and Alex's parents decide the leisure life is not for them and move out of Ocean Tide. Dopey plotting, cranky characters, but lavish detail about the accoutrements of $5,000 bicycles.