From Publishers Weekly
W called this story of a couple who take an airplane trip to adopt a baby girl "an ebullient tribute for families whose members may have come from a faraway place." Ages 2-8. Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 1. Bright, fanciful folk-art illustrations set the mood for (but occasionally get in the way of) this loving story of adoption. The smoothly flowing text is reassuring throughout, reflecting the joy of the new parents and ending with the "forever and always" that is the promise of adoption. The foster parents ("the kind people who had taken care of her") are pictured. The first day includes the first telling of the adoption story to the baby girl, "You grew like a flower in another lady's tummy." However, the first couple of illustrations are problematic. On the first spread, a baby is shown alone on a hillside sitting on a beanbag cloud with a city in the distance. The text states: "Once upon a time a teeny-tiny baby was born." Babies aren't born alone on hillsides, and even though this one is smiling, the picture doesn't seem reassuring. Adopted children need to know that they were born like other children, and did not appear magically without human connection. Also, though the text realistically recounts the new parents' first-day nervousness, the baby is pictured as smiling throughout instead of showing a range of reactions to different activities and situations.?Nancy Schimmel, formerly at San Mateo County Library, CACopyright 1997 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Kirkus Reviews
A happy, colorful book about a man and woman dreaming of their soon-to-be-born adopted baby, receiving the news of her birth, and flying to the ``faraway place'' where they meet their child. Based on Katz's experience adopting a Central American infant and bright with mixed-media illustrations suggestive of folk art, this is a book for adults to use with children who were adopted in similar circumstances. The message is reassuring: ``Forever and always we will be your mommy and daddy. Forever and always you will be our child.'' The birth mother is gently described as another lady in whose tummy ``you grew like a flower,'' but who ``wasn't able to take care of you, so Mommy and Daddy came to adopt you and bring you home.'' The baby has dark hair like the mother's and dark eyes like both parents' but with duskier skin than either. As in Jamie Lee Curtis and Laura Cornell's Tell Me Again About the Night I Was Born (1996), both text and pictures are suffused with anticipation and joyful welcome at the baby's arrival. (Picture book. 3-7) -- Copyright ©1997, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved.
Over the Moon: An Adoption Tale ANNOTATION
A loving couple dream of a baby born far away and know that this is the baby they have been waiting to adopt.
FROM THE PUBLISHER
An affirming story about international adoption, based on the author's own experience with her daughter.
A magical, reassuring story of one adoptive family's beginnings, told in words and pictures that are just right for the youngest child.
FROM THE CRITICS
Publishers Weekly
There is a contagious exuberance to newcomer Katz's playfully stylized collage, gouache and colored pencil illustrations, which display a vibrant palette and all the energy of a flamenco dance. The story, too, has a joyous ring, as it follows a couple's airplane trip "over the moon and through the night" to a "faraway place" where they adopt a baby girl. The story has ample measures of fantasy (on the night their baby is born, the soon-to-be mom and dad each dream of the baby they had been "longing for") and lyricism (lying on a blanket watching the stars, the couple tell the baby, "You grew like a flower in another lady's tummy until you were born"). The artwork accentuates the joy that bursts from the parents-to-be: when the happy phone call comes saying the baby has been born, they float above the town like Chagall characters. With its poetic flair and fanciful art, Katz's treatment is an interesting contrast to Allen Say's Allison (see review below), which presents the adoption issue from a more forthright perspective. Inspired by the author's own daughter, who was adopted from Central America, this is an ebullient tribute for families whose members may have come from a faraway place. Ages 2-8. (Sept.)
Children's Literature - Jeanne K. Pettenati
This colorful adoption tale illustrates the journey traveled by adoptive parents to meet their daughter and become a family. The journey begins when a baby is born and her parents dream about her before they actually meet her. The book depicts the sheer joy and the intensity of love these parents feel when finally united with their long awaited child. The book's message is that adoption is a wonderful and permanent way to create a family. "Forever and always we will be your mommy and daddy. Forever and always you will be our child," the baby's parents tell her. The bright illustrations, characterized by magical realism, are reminiscent of an island adventure. This tale is an appealing choice for adoption libraries.
Parent Council Reviews
This is an outstanding book for young children about international adoption. The text is joyful and reassuring, but the real delight is the illustrations which are colorful quilted folk art designs. My adopted daughter loved the book because she could read it herself. We both were fascinated by the illustrations and enjoyed going through the book over and over again to look for more things embedded in the pictures. 2001, Henry Holt and Company, $6.95. Ages 3 to 8. Reviewer: S. Latson SOURCE: Parent Council Volume 8
School Library Journal
PreS-Gr 1Bright, fanciful folk-art illustrations set the mood for (but occasionally get in the way of) this loving story of adoption. The smoothly flowing text is reassuring throughout, reflecting the joy of the new parents and ending with the "forever and always" that is the promise of adoption. The foster parents ("the kind people who had taken care of her") are pictured. The first day includes the first telling of the adoption story to the baby girl, "You grew like a flower in another lady's tummy." However, the first couple of illustrations are problematic. On the first spread, a baby is shown alone on a hillside sitting on a beanbag cloud with a city in the distance. The text states: "Once upon a time a teeny-tiny baby was born." Babies aren't born alone on hillsides, and even though this one is smiling, the picture doesn't seem reassuring. Adopted children need to know that they were born like other children, and did not appear magically without human connection. Also, though the text realistically recounts the new parents' first-day nervousness, the baby is pictured as smiling throughout instead of showing a range of reactions to different activities and situations.Nancy Schimmel, formerly at San Mateo County Library, CA
Kirkus Reviews
A happy, colorful book about a man and woman dreaming of their soon-to-be-born adopted baby, receiving the news of her birth, and flying to the "faraway place" where they meet their child. Based on Katz's experience adopting a Central American infant and bright with mixed-media illustrations suggestive of folk art, this is a book for adults to use with children who were adopted in similar circumstances. The message is reassuring: "Forever and always we will be your mommy and daddy. Forever and always you will be our child." The birth mother is gently described as another lady in whose tummy "you grew like a flower," but who "wasn't able to take care of you, so Mommy and Daddy came to adopt you and bring you home." The baby has dark hair like the mother's and dark eyes like both parents' but with duskier skin than either. As in Jamie Lee Curtis and Laura Cornell's Tell Me Again About the Night I Was Born (1996), both text and pictures are suffused with anticipation and joyful welcome at the baby's arrival.