From Publishers Weekly
Canadian Engel's serviceable venture into the Sherlock Holmes genre suffers by comparison to David Pirie's The Patient's Eyes (2002), likewise substituting a young Arthur Conan Doyle and his real-life mentor, Dr. Joseph Bell, for Watson and Holmes. When a beautiful opera singer and her lover are found brutally slain, suspicion falls on Alan Lambert, "a man of good family fallen upon evil days," whose brother asks Bell for assistance. As the doctor and his protege race the clock to save Lambert from the gallows, Edinburgh's power elite impedes their efforts at every turn. Undeterred, the pair persists in exploring numerous avenues of inquiry that the police have ignored or discounted. While the period details ring true and Bell is a convincing master detective, with his deductions based on careful observation and encyclopedic knowledge, his personality remains far less developed than that of Pirie's hero. Similarly, Engel barely alludes to Doyle's well-documented family difficulties, which provided Pirie with ample grist for making the future creator of Sherlock Holmes sympathetic and complex. Moreover, the murderer's identity will come as less than a surprise to most readers.Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.

Book Description
A dead opera star, a brilliant anatomy professor with Sherlockian powers of deduction and a moody Victorian backdrop--it all adds up to a thrillingly entertaining historical mystery. Howard Engel is the award-winning writer whose Benny Cooperman mysteries garner rave international reviews--fans stretch to thirteen countries from Canada to Japan, England, Germany, Italy, Spain, Denmark, and the U.S. His latest, Mr. Doyle and Dr. Bell, is a brilliant departure from the Cooperman series, set in the Edinburgh of late 1800s and peopled with such illustrious historical figures as Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Robert Louis Stevenson, and Benjamin Disraeli. Julian Symons called Engel's first non-series mystery Murder in Montparnasse first class entertainment, stylishly written . . . Engel can turn a phrase as neatly as Chandler." The year is 1879 and Alan Lambert has been tried, convicted and sentenced to hang for the murder of a dazzling opera star and her lover. But Lambert's brother believes in his innocence and pleads with Dr. Bell, a celebrated professor of anatomy, to uncover the truth. Dr. Bell agrees and sets out to crack the case, with his keen powers of deduction and the help of his young student, Arthur Conan Doyle. The exuberant plot of Mr. Doyle and Dr. Bell carries readers across the roof tops of Edinburgh and descends into the thickets of municipal corruption. Fans of Sherlock Holmes will immediately recognize Holmes in Dr. Joseph Bell, who in real life was Conan Doyle's model for his famous sleuth.

FROM THE PUBLISHER

The year is 1879, and Alan Lambert has been tried, convicted, and sentenced to hang for the murder of a dazzling opera star and her lover. But Lambert's brother believes that Alan is innocent and pleads with Dr. Joseph Bell, a celebrated professor of anatomy, to uncover the truth. Dr. Bell agrees and sets out to crack the case - with his keen powers of deduction and the help of his young student, Arthur Conan Doyle. Together, Bell and Doyle embark on a race against the hangman with Lambert's cries of innocence ringing in their ears.

FROM THE CRITICS

Publishers Weekly

Canadian Engel's serviceable venture into the Sherlock Holmes genre suffers by comparison to David Pirie's The Patient's Eyes (2002), likewise substituting a young Arthur Conan Doyle and his real-life mentor, Dr. Joseph Bell, for Watson and Holmes. When a beautiful opera singer and her lover are found brutally slain, suspicion falls on Alan Lambert, "a man of good family fallen upon evil days," whose brother asks Bell for assistance. As the doctor and his protege race the clock to save Lambert from the gallows, Edinburgh's power elite impedes their efforts at every turn. Undeterred, the pair persists in exploring numerous avenues of inquiry that the police have ignored or discounted. While the period details ring true and Bell is a convincing master detective, with his deductions based on careful observation and encyclopedic knowledge, his personality remains far less developed than that of Pirie's hero. Similarly, Engel barely alludes to Doyle's well-documented family difficulties, which provided Pirie with ample grist for making the future creator of Sherlock Holmes sympathetic and complex. Moreover, the murderer's identity will come as less than a surprise to most readers. (July) FYI: Arthur Ellis Award-winner Engel is also the author of The Cooperman Variations (2002) and other titles in his Benny Cooperman series. Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.

Library Journal

A youthful Arthur Conan Doyle, attending medical school in Edinburgh in 1879, partners with his anatomy professor, Dr. Joseph Bell (who in real life served as the model for Sherlock Holmes), as they investigate the murder of a celebrated opera star and her lover. The case has all the hallmarks of a Holmesian puzzle, including a ten-minute window of time, bolted doors, peculiarities of blood spatter, a witness who needs glasses, police corruption, etc. In addition, a black sheep of good family stands accused of the crime. This most intriguing setup, coupled with superlative investigative techniques and eminently readable prose, should prove popular to mystery fans who also enjoyed "Murder Rooms," a PBS Mystery! series about Conan Doyle and Bell. From the author of the Benny Cooperman novels. Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.

Kirkus Reviews